What is manuscript evaluation?
A big-picture assessment of your story, focusing on how it reads as a whole. It looks at structure, pacing, character, and overall cohesion, without going into detailed, line-by-line commentary.
This service is designed to give you clear, focused insight into what is working, what may need attention, and how your manuscript can be strengthened before moving into deeper revision,
all while preserving your unique voice.
WHAT IT IS NOT:
This is not a full developmental edit. It does not include detailed inline comments or chapter-by-chapter feedback. No proofreading or stylistic edits.
Instead, it offers a broader perspective, allowing you to step back and see your manuscript with greater clarity before committing to more in-depth editing.
Plot & Pacing
Observe the high-level trajectory of your novel, identifying where momentum builds and where the rhythm needs tuning.
Character & Voice
Examine character motivations, arcs, point of view to ensure they are relatable, consistent, and undergo growth.
The Pillars of Evaluation
A manuscript evaluation focuses on the early-stage health of your story, offering an encouraging map for your next draft without getting lost in deep level line-by-line edits.
What's included?
An editorial letter detailing overview of your manuscript, outlining strengths, key issues, and clear guidance for next steps.
Want to see my evaluation style? Request a free 2000 word sample edit.
Worldbuilding
Review the foundations of your world to ensure consistency, internal logic, and a setting that supports your narrative.
Revision Focus
Identify key areas for revision and provide clear, structured guidance so you know where to direct your attention.
The evaluation process
01
Submission & Vision
03
The Path Forward
The process begins with sharing your manuscript and defining your goals. I immerse myself in your creative goals to ensure our vision for the story's heart is perfectly aligned.
You receive a comprehensive assessment report outlining market fit and narrative cohesion. We conclude with an encouraging strategy session to map out your manuscript’s next evolution.
02
Structural Deep Read
I perform a panoramic analysis of your manuscript, identifying structural friction points in plot architecture, pacing, and character development without the distraction of line edits.